RAILTRACK Media Quotes


ERRORS ALL THE WAY DOWN THE LINE ---
THE CULLEN REPORT ON THE PADDINGTON RAIL DISASTER
"RAILTRACK was sent three written warnings before the crash by ALISON FORSTER, operations and safety director for FIRST GREAT WESTERN, which were ignored... Mr McNAUGHTON, one RAILTRACK director, told the inquiry that the Great Western zone he managed had been 'declining for at least a decade', while 'the culture of the place had gone seriously adrift over the years.'

"A combination of 'incompetent management and inadequate procedures' meant that signal sighting committees persistently failed to meet, while, despite a number of measures being mooted, 'very little' had been achieved to improve safety...

SARAH HALL - THE GUARDIAN 20 June 2001


LABOUR WILL SELL RAILTRACK TO BECHTEL AFTER THE ELECTION -- SUBSIDISED BY THE TAXPAYER, OF COURSE!!!
THE OBSERVER learnt this weekend that a new Blair government would not "stand in the way" of worthy candidates and might approach potential buyers itself. Senior industry sources said companies such as US construction giant Bechtel [WHOSE MANAGEMENT FORMED MUCH OF RONALD REAGAN'S CABINET, AND WHICH HAS BEEN INVOLVED IN MASSIVE OVER-EXPENDITURE OF PUBLIC MONEY ON NUCLEAR POWER STATIONS AND MILITARY CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS IN THE US], Britain's John Laing [ALREADY ONE OF RAILTRACK'S DISASTROUS "MAINTENANCE" PARTNERS] and the venture capital arm of the Japanese bank Nomura [OWNER OF VARIOUS "TRAIN OPERATING COMPANIES" AND FAILED SAVIOUR OF THE "MILLENIUM DOME"] could team up to take over Railtrack and then split it up, or buy part of the business if it was spun off.

... Railtrack has admitted it is in no position to deliver on its promises, with its value decimated after it ignored the broken rail which caused last year's Hatfield crash... In other words, forget those early promises and also assume that the taxpayer will supply a greater proportion needed by the industry, via the Government and its agent, the SRA.

JOANNA WALTERS - THE OBSERVER 27 APRIL 2001


RAILTRACK "FACING BANKRUPTCY"
Railtrack was last night said to be facing bankruptcy amid allegations by the rail industry regulator that it was incapable of managing its business. The charge came as Railtrack confirmed that it had approached the government for an extra £2 billion... Senior sources in the SRA said: "Railtrack is close to bankruptcy. It cannot survive as it is without the injection of further government money." SIR ALASTAIR MORTON, the SRA's chairman, has ordered a halt to any further funding for rail maintenance because it is appalled at the way Railtrack is managing the network. His decision has been backed by the SRA's board... A senior industry source said... Railtrack could be sold off to the international infrastructure firm, BECHTEL, if ministers were not prepared to take it back into state ownership. The sources said the government still appeared reluctant to take any action against Railtrack until after the election...

KEITH HARPER -Monday February 19, 2001 THE GUARDIAN


EVERYBODY HATES RAILTRACK
"Everybody hates Railtrack, the privatised company that
makes £1 million pure profit every day while presiding over
the collapse of the nation's train system... it has become a
money-laundering operation for state subsidies."

MARTIN BRIGHT - THE OBSERVER,  4 Oct 1998


RAILTRACK ASTONISHED THE GOVERNMENT
"Railtrack astonished the government by pressing for a new
subsidy of £1 billion at a time when it is reaching only 50%
of its punctuality targets for passenger trains."

KEITH HARPER
THE GUARDIAN,  26 March 1999

TAXPAYERS CHEATED OUT OF BILLIONS
"The cross-party parliamentary Public Accounts Committe last
night declared that British taxpayers were cheated out of
billions of pounds by the privatisation of Railtrack.  It
said the sale of shares should have been staggered to
capture their stellar rise in value after the 1996 sell-
off."

THE GUARDIAN, 14 July 1999

TAXPAYERS SHORTCHANGED "ON AN HEROIC SCALE"
"Rail privatisation shortchanged the taxpayers on an heroic
scale because of the speed with which it was done.  Those
who cashed in were the buyers of the assets, very often
former British Rail executives, who became overnight
millionaires as they later sold on their businesses at vast
profit."

MICHAEL HARRISON
THE INDEPENDENT, 21 Oct 2000

THE VALUE OF A HUMAN LIFE
"British Rail publicly expressed its commitment to "absolute
safety" saying that this "must be a gospel... paramount in
the minds of management."

"Yet immediately upon privatisation this commitment was
abandoned.  Instead of talking about absolute safety...
Railtrack and Great Western trains began to talk about cost
benefit analysis and the value of saving a life.  They put
the value of a human life as not more than £2.76 million,
and said they were not prepared to afford the cost they
calculated as being at £14 million per life of installing
ATP [Automatic Train Protection]."

LOUISE CHRISTIAN
THE GUARDIAN, 6 Oct 1999


MAXIMUM SAFETY VS. PROFIT MAXIMISATION
"It is hardly surprising that the [privatized water] company
KELDA should have proposed putting its water and sewerage
interests, Yorkshire Water, into a new mutual structure. 
Under the plans, the customers would become the owners,
finance the purchase by raising bonds and finance te debt at
low cost from the rock-solid income stream that a utility
provides...

"The same principle applies, of course, to the railways,
where there is a world of diffference between an investor-
driven model in which the safety of passengers is important
but balanced against the interest of investors and a mutual
model in which the safety of passengers is everything...

"Under a mutual system, investor ownership is replaced by
community ownership , with those running companies obliged
to act in the best interests of the community not the
corporation.   Freed from the tyranies of profit
maximisation, companies that provide a public service could
be obliged to make safety or operational efficiency their
guiding principles."

LARRY ELLIOT
THE GUARDIAN, 13 Nov 2000


BETTER TIMES FOR RAILTRACK
"Railtrack this week told its shareholders that "better
times are to come."  So they raised the dividend for
shareholders by 5% (underlying inflation is 2%)...

"The Treasury's 10-year plan for the railways is investing
£29 billion of public money....  Railtrack is now worth £5
billion.  From 1997 to this March, Labour had already paid
out exactly that sum in railway subsidy, with much more to
come.  So why doesn't the goverment own it by now - or at
least a significant slice of the shares?"

POLLY TONYBEE
THE GUARDIAN, 15 Nov 2000


RAILTRACK RENATIONALISATION GAINING SUPPORT
"An early day motion on renationalising Railtrack already has more than 70 supporters (in Parliament)"

ROS COWARD
THE GUARDIAN, 19 DEC 2000

NUMBER CRUNCHING
£400,000 -- Golden handshake given to former Railtrack chief executive Gerald Corbett. £400,000 -- Cost of fifty Railtrack signallers for one year.

SIGNAL FAILURES - PRIVATE EYE #1017
15 Dec
2000


FRENCH ATTACK RAILTRACK
"The French cried "foul" on the British yesterday and attacked Railtrack's threat to pull out of the second stage of the Channel Tunnel rail link. The criticism came from Guillaume Pepy, director of passenger services for SNCF, the French state-owned railway, in a put-down of Britain's dilapidated railway system... Mr Pepy said: "I am shocked. It's nonsense. It's incredible." Mr Pepy, whose company has a big stake in Eurostar, said that the 72-mile journey from Folkestone to London on Eurostar was "sometimes a nightmare."... Jean Francois Bernard, director general of RFF, a publicly owned company but otherwise the equivalent of Railtrack, said: "Because the British system is private, it is bad, and it is bad for safety." SNCF receives £2.1 billion from the French government to run its services compared with the £1.3 billion which the 25 train operating companies get in Britain. RRF [sic] gets £1 billion from the French government to maintain the railways."

KEITH HARPER
THE GUARDIAN 18 JAN 2001


RAILTRACK SPARED PUBLIC CRASH ENQUIRY
Ministers have ruled out a public enquiry into the Hatfield rail disaster "because they have no stomach for it" and want to avoid a third embarrassing inquiry into a train crash in less than three years... The decision was taken by the transport minister LORD MACDONALD, after a meeting with health and safety inspectors and accident investigators. Ministers are anxious to keep what is rapidly becoming a politically sensitive issue as low key as possible in the lead up to the election... Criminal prosecutions for manslaughter are expected to be laid against up to six named staff at RAILTRACK and BALFOUR BEATTY as a direct result of the Hatfield Crash...

KEITH HARPER
REBECCA ALLISON
THE GUARDIAN 22 January 2001



Should RAILTRACK be Renationalised?

Yes it should
No it shouldn't


View Results*
*Clicking on VOTE will take you to another site containing a banner-ad not endorsed by Renationalise.com. Please use the link provided or your BACK button to return


HOME